Hayley Mills

Nancy Carey

Burl Ives

Osh Popham

Dorothy McGuire

Mrs. Margaret Carey

Deborah Walley

Julia Carey

Una Merkel

Mariah Popham

Eddie Hodges

Gilly Carey

Michael J. Pollard

Digby Popham

Peter Brown

Tom Hamilton

James Stacy

Charles Bryant

James Mathers

Peter Carey (as Jimmy Mathers)

O.Z. Whitehead

Mr. Perkins

Wendy Turner

Lallie Joy Popham

Harry Holcombe

Rev. Henry Lord

Hilda Plowright

Mary

Norman Leavitt

Hank Champlin, the barber (uncredited)

Jan Stine

Tad Perkins (uncredited)

Eddie Quillan

Boston Mailman (uncredited)

Paul E. Burns

Drinker (uncredited)

Ina Kent

Opal (uncredited)

Marcy McGuire

Ellen (uncredited)